Value Added: When the Right Stuff Never Grows Old

Check out how the tactical advantages provided by a decades-old laser, brake and shear generate productivity that bolsters the business plan of this Canadian fab shop.

Other than conversation pieces, what’s the value in having decades-old machine tools occupy valuable floor space in a modern fab shop? The answer is “plenty!” according to Ken Lennox, provided the machines are in suitable roles and were originally built with “the right stuff.”

Lennox runs his business, ETSM Technical Services Ltd. (Guelph, Ontario), with his son, Matt. ETSM is an excellent case in point, with a mechanical brake from the fifties, a shear from the seventies, and a mid-eighties laser cutting system, all built by Cincinnati Incorporated (Cincinnati, OH). These three machines continue to be used daily in the shop, within sight of state-of-the-art equipment that includes another Cincinnati brake and laser as new as 2011.

ETSM is a well-balanced business in Guelph that manufactures its own product line of coil winding systems, enclosures and related equipment for the electrical transformer and utility industries. Their plants also produce custom fabrications, machine guarding, automotive fixturing and replacement parts for regional customers in energy, automotive and mining industries.

The company has three principal lines of business: machining, powder coating and custom fabrication. ETSM employs about 50 people and operates out of two production facilities totaling about 50,000 sq ft. As a manufacturer of its own product line, the company has an engineering and controls department, as well as assembly capability.

“Our engineering, assembly, machining, fabrication and finishing capabilities give us a lot of flexibility and many of our employees are multi-skilled,” says ETSM president Lennox. “We’re a one-stop shop for fairly complex systems and machinery, while we can still make a nice profit doing repairs, one-off projects, or walk-in work.”

Lennox started this business in 1985 with used fabrication equipment that included a Cincinnati 5 Series 125 ton mechanical press brake made in 1954, followed shortly by a used 18 Series shear with ¼ in x 10 ft capacity, built in 1974. The company’s first commercial laser cutting system was also a used Cincinnati CL-7, built in 1987 for the manufacturer’s own shop and used heavily for a couple of decades before being sold to a surplus dealer.

“We have the technical resources in-house to modernize these machines with current safety systems and guarding,” notes Lennox. “We installed a CNC back gauge on the press brake, and a new Fanuc control and servos on the laser system.”

TACTICAL ADVANTAGES TO KEEPING OLDER MACHINES IN SERVICE
But why keep these machines in production when the company has a new Cincinnati CL-840 laser and newer 60CBII press brake, as well as other new equipment?

“We often have work that we don’t want to use our new equipment for, or the old machines have a slight edge for some things,” explains Lennox. “For example, we use the mechanical brake for lighter duty work that does not require its full capacity, such as straightening a fabrication we just made in our shop. This is a very tough, fast and durable machine. On a high-production run, it’s faster than a hydraulic brake so gives us a time advantage. There are worn components on it, but it still works great.”

ETSM originally planned to retire the 1200 watt CL-7 laser when they got the 4000 watt 840, “but we never quit using the older machine because it fills a niche for us,” adds Lennox. “We do a lot of quick one-off pieces, and by keeping the older machine we do not have to interrupt a production run on our higher-end laser. We can switch it from 20 ga to ¼ in plate quicker than the new machine because it’s lower-level technology. Just change the power settings and run it. It has the same 5 ft x 10 ft table and swappable pallets.”

Lennox admits that the older machine is slower with ballscrew drives and does not produce the same edge quality or accuracy as the new laser. But for a segment of his business this is simply not an issue. The ability to get one part made in a few minutes, without interrupting the new laser, gives ETSM a competitive advantage for some jobs.

The newer CL-840 laser uses Cincinnati’s third-generation linear motor drives which combine with a 4000 watt resonator for up to 1000 ipm cutting of 20 ga steel with ±0.001 in accuracy. Like the older machine, its frame is built with heavyweight 0.75 in to 1.5 in steel plate, double the weight of other lasers, to resist the G-forces generated by linear motor acc/dec and deliver long service life in tough shop conditions.

The CL-840 laser uses dual 5 ft x 10 ft quick-change pallets to enable offline load/unload and near-non-stop cutting. Among the products manufactured in volume on this new laser are electrical enclosures that house phone and cable TV lines inside concrete light poles. ETSM makes about 5,000 kits for these enclosures every year.

Each kit uses satin galvanized steel, aluminum and stainless steel. “Prior to our new laser, we outsourced everything but the mild steel, which we cut with our old laser,” recalls Lennox. “The new laser allowed us to bring all of this work in house, particularly the lighter gauge aluminum and stainless.”

Other items fabricated in quantity at ETSM include development-size lots of parking lot equipment.

Likewise, the Cincinnati 18 Series shear made in 1974 continues to serve a role after being purchased as used equipment more than 20 years ago. The machine was built in Cincinnati Incorporated’s former manufacturing plant in Scotland, sold to a customer in Israel, and then to a brake pad manufacturer in Montreal from whom Lennox bought the machine.

“We use it every day and have no plans to replace it, despite having laser cutting ability,” stresses Lennox. “It’s pretty much maintenance-free. Just change the blades as needed and wipe the dust off. These older machines all still work. They rarely need maintenance. And there’s no cost to keep them on the floor. In fact, the older equipment is often easier to maintain because it’s simpler.”

LESSONS FROM “UNDER THE HOOD”
Lennox says his early experiences at an employer’s shop shaped his views on equipment. “I learned my craft working under the hood of machine tools, repairing them and adding accessories/upgrades, so I know what to look for and it has made me a discriminating buyer of equipment,” he explains.

During those early years, Lennox was all over Cincinnati machines at various times. In one case, they built a feeder for a large press brake that was going to be used for curving multi-plate tunnel liner. In another case, he had to repair the back gauge on a 3/8 in x 16 ft Cincinnati shear.

“I learned that Cincinnati does not skimp on the material that is the foundation of the machine,” smiles Lennox. “What I saw of various types of equipment during that time still shapes my thinking today. There is something to be said for having lots of mass in a machine that’s going to be heavily used – and often abused – in a North American fab shop. Today, within any group of machine tools rated the same, there will be some that weigh a fraction of what others weigh. In my experience, the heavyweights survive better for the longest working lives.”

Lennox emphasizes that those survivors will outlive their controls, so an upgrade path is important, as are current safety systems. “Cincinnati has an excellent control upgrade available for our 60 ton press brake built in 1998 with a 72 in bed,” he says. “We’re planning to replace our large foreign-built press brake with a Cincinnati in the future and will implement the control upgrade for the 60CBII machine at that time so that we can have one training and start-up period for two machines.”

As a builder of machine guarding, ETSM has the resources to keep its machines current with safety standards, too. The company has in-house capabilities for fabricating enclosures and perimeter guarding and integrating sensors with machine control systems.

The company also works with a safety consultant to ensure its shop and equipment meet current standards. Lennox says ETSM purchased its CL-840 laser with the Lexan enclosure and liked it so well that it plans to fabricate a similar enclosure for its older laser.

“There’s no capital cost to keep these older machines,” states Lennox. “As long as they stay healthy and we don’t need the floor space desperately, we’ll continue to use them because they fill an important tactical role in our business plan.”

Cincinnati Incorporated, Box 11111, Cincinnati, OH 45211, 513-367-7100, Fax: 513-367-7552, info@e-ci.com, www.e-ci.com.