Busted: 5 Myths About Metal-Cored Welding Wire
Metal-cored wire isn’t new, but there are often misconceptions about applications, cost, performance, strength, and workability compared to solid wire. Read on to learn how you might be missing opportunities to increase welding operation productivity for less cost.
Posted: March 25, 2020
MELTING POINT COLUMN
By Caleb Haven
Metal-cored wire isn’t new, but many in the welding industry are still unfamiliar with the technology. Because of this, there are often misconceptions about how it operates compared to solid wire, and the cost associated with the product.
Let’s bust five myths about this consumable.
Myth No. 1: Metal-cored wire is only for semi-automatic welding.
Metal-cored wire actually performs well in robotic welding applications, too.
The wire’s tubular design produces a broad penetration profile, offering greater tolerance for part fit-up and gap handling than solid wires. This feature can compensate for inaccurate stampings or offset tooling in robotic welding applications.
Metal-cored wire can also provide faster travel speeds and higher deposition rates than solid wire, which adds to the high level of productivity companies seek from robotic welding systems.
High weld quality is another benefit. The wire has a smooth, wide bead appearance; offers excellent mechanical properties; and produces little to no spatter. Because uptime is key in robotic welding applications, the reduction in post-weld spatter cleanup makes for faster production.
Myth No. 2: Metal-cored wire costs more, so it increases welding expenses.
Per pound, metal-cored wire does typically cost more than other solid wire. However, its attributes can reduce overall costs in a welding operation.
Metal-cored wire can weld through dirt, oil, and mill scale; and it produces very little spatter. As a result, the wire can eliminate nonvalue-added pre- and post-weld activities.
Non-value-added activities are those that don’t contribute to throughput, such as grinding, chipping, sandblasting, and applying anti-spatter compound. Not having to perform these activities reduces labor and supply costs. In some cases, companies can reallocate labor to other parts of the welding operation to take on tasks that increase productivity.
The faster travel speeds and higher deposition rates provided by metal-cored wire also make it possible to produce more parts in less time, increasing overall revenue.
Myth No. 3: Metal-cored wire can’t be used for pulsed MIG welding.
Welding operators can gain the same forgiveness, ease-of-use, and high deposition rates from pulsed MIG welding with metal-cored wires as when welding flat and horizontal with a CV power source. For out-of-position welding with metal-cored wire, pulsing is actually necessary to maintain control of the weld pool.
Today’s power sources feature sophisticated pulsed wave capabilities, making it possible to maintain a stable arc and achieve consistent weld quality with metal-cored wires.
Myth No. 4: Metal-cored wire has different strength properties than solid wire.
Typical metal-cored wire and a solid wire are classified under the same American Welding Society (AWS) standard, providing the same minimum tensile and yield strength as well as the same elongation and Charpy V-notch (CVN) impact properties.
For example, a metal-cored wire with an AWS E70C-6M classification and an AWS E70S-6 solid wire are both classified under A5.18: Specification for Carbon Steel Electrodes and Rods for Gas-Shielded Arc Welding. Because the wires are formulated and tested to this specification, they both meet the AWS minimum tensile strength requirements of 70,000 psi and yield strength minimum of 58,000 psi. They offer the AWS minimum of 22% elongation and CVN impacts of 20 ft/lbs (27 Joules) at -20 degrees Fahrenheit.
Myth No. 5: Metal-cored wire is harder to weld with than solid wire.
In semi-automatic applications, welding operators will notice that metal-cored wire welds faster than solid wire. That doesn’t mean that it’s more difficult to operate. The overall technique of welding with metal-cored wire is the same as solid wire in terms of torch angles. A 10-to-15-degree push angle is a good starting point.
Metal-cored wire in some respects is also more forgiving.
For example, the wider arc cone allows for slight variations in joint placement without sacrificing weld quality, making it easier for new or less skilled welding operators to put down quality welds. Operators can make larger beads without having to weave or manipulate the welding gun or weld pool.
It’s also possible to use longer welding wire stickouts. The contact-tip-to-work distance can be longer — usually between 1/2 inch and 1 inch, depending on wire diameter. Finally, the wider arc cone allows for greater tolerance of gaps and poor part fit-up, reducing the chances of burning through the base material.
Parting thoughts
In the right applications, metal-cored wire can provide high weld quality and productivity. It excels at welding parts prone to burn-through and instances of poor part fit up, for example. It’s also a good option for welding operations struggling to train less skilled welders, since it’s easy to use. And, it’s a good alternative to solid wire when welding on 1.5 mm and thicker steel.
As with any welding wire technology, contact a trusted filler metal manufacturer or welding distributor with any questions about metal-cored wire.
Subscribe to learn the latest in manufacturing.
